• Aaron Hernandez left a message of eternal life as he willfully took his own life in prison - Aaron Hernandez was a gifted athlete who led a troubled life. But his suicide caught friends and family by surprise, a week after an quital in court on another case. ...
• Frosty the Snowman provided a chilly break from Florida’s warmer winter weather - Visiting up North was an experience that a Floridian could enjoy, but coming home to warmer weather makes one appreciate Florida. ...
• Women prisoners count their blessings on a tearful Thanksgiving at Lowell Prison - Visits on Thanksgiving were all too short at Lowell Prison where children were asking "Why can't I stay with Mommy?" Columnist Jack Strickland visits at Lowell and writes a riveting story about the emotions of the day as families got together all too briefly. He came away with both a feeling of sadness and of joy. ...
• “Souls to the Polls” march re-enacts history to inspire students at FAMU to vote in the election - FAMU students recreated history on Sunday with a march to the polls to demonstrate the importance of voting and to inspire students to vote in the national election. ...
• Florida women’s prison is nightmare as prisoners endure humiliation, poor medical care, rip-offs - Florida's major prison for women is an endless nightmare for those who have to endure the permanent psychological scarring that results from little privacy, no meaningful rehabilitation, general neglect of medical care by the prisons, and the rip-off of high prices for phone calls and items supplied by private contractors. ...
• Question is whether Adelson family was involved in Markel murder, and motives of the suspects - Questions remain unanswered about release of evidence and possible motives for murder - were suspects trying to extort money from Adelsons? ...
• Small explosion causes chaos at Florida A&M University - An explosion at the FAMU campus Thursday was actually a dishwasher catching fire. However it did cause a scare among faculty, staff and students at the Presidential Dining Hall. ...
• In a surprise appearance, Shaq has a ball inspiring neighborhood kids to dream big - A surprise visit by the former star basketball player to Gainesville and the police department brought out good feelings all around as kids got to play with superstar. ...
• ‘Cash register justice’ for the poor means no justice for many in Florida courts - Prosecutors now seek to extract fees from indigent defendents to help pay office costs, causing possible miscarriage of justice, says national justice center. ...
• If Jeb Bush ever really went to prison in Florida, he wouldn’t get a happy reception - The disaster of corruption, privatized prisons, and loss of competent leadership in state prisons is Jeb Bush’s legacy in Florida. ...
• Court fails to convict police officer in NC shooting death of former FAMU football player - Family pleads for calm as jury fails to find officer guilty in shooting death of Jonathan Ferrell in Charlotte; no decision yet on retrial. ...
• Carson wins best dressed while Trump brings up the rear in the clash of haberdashery at GOP debate - Who was dressed to win the recent GOP debate? Who wore the most stunning tie, and the best cut suit? Looks like neurosurgeon Ben Carson knows how to dress. Donald Trump, who sells a line of clothing, ironically finishes last. ...
• FSU could receive NCAA sanctions similar to those of Penn State sex scandal - Recent events will add up to more problems for Florida State University when NCAA and Title IX investigators report their findings. ...
• Gators end Florida State’s baseball hopes in big wins in Gainesville; on to the Series - Getting back into the College World Series was a dream for both teams, but the Gators managed to teach Florida State a lesson or two. ...
• Miracle of heart transplant puts ‘inoperable’ Rachel, 10, back in the arms of her new family - The dramatic story of how 10-year-old Rachel McCary got her new heart and a new chance to live is told by Jack Strickland who watched closely at the hospital in Gainesville while a miracle was performed. ...
|Lowest Gas Prices in Tallahassee|
|Tallahassee - Gas Prices provided by GasBuddy.com|
» By the numbers: How Trump stacks up after 100 days
» How artists are marking Trump's 100th day in office
» Former DNC chair slams Trump's 'irrational and extreme agenda'
» Trump: Don't worry, we'll build the wall
» Protesters take on Trump's climate policies -- and the heat
» EPA removes climate change information from website
» Del. senator slams Trump's N. Korea tweet: 'No longer reality TV'
» Democrats' Senate math problem
» Trump labels MS-13 public enemy No.1
» US yellow fever vaccine supply will run out this summer, CDC says
NPR National Headlines
» U.S. Rep. Ros-Lehtinen, First Cuban-American Elected to Congress, Retiring Next Year
» How Lives On Both Sides Of Border Towns Have Changed Since Trump Took Office
» Barbershop: Trump's Contentious, Yet Symbiotic Relationship With The Media
» Trump Invites Controversial Philippines Leader To White House
» Trump Stars On Stage He Built Himself, Far From Washington
» President Trump's First 100 Days, In Photos
» The Los Angeles Riots, Race And Journalism
» Reporters Gather For White House Correspondents' Dinner
» Thousands March In D.C. To Protest Trump Climate Policies
» The Call-In: Your Stories About Veterans Affairs
CNN World Headlines
‘Cash register justice’ for the poor means no justice for many in Florida courtsNovember 16, 2015
By: Jack Strickland
By Jack Strickland
Cash register justice is flourishing in Florida. These days, In criminal courts in the Sunshine State, you can get the amount of justice you can afford to buy.
Defendants with money can expect to get more favorable treatment in court, and shorter jail sentences, than those who who are broke and unable to pay, when they come before the courts.
Rex Dimmig, the Public Defender for Florida’s 10th judicial circuit, protested the practice last week. He said people he represents are given a choice: Pay hundreds of dollars to the court to help fund the prosecutor’s office and get a favorable plea bargain, or go to trial and risk a longer prison sentence and/or harsher punishment. Dimmig claims this practice creates unequal justice under the law for the poor people who come before a judge. He says the practice violates the constitutional guarantee of equal protection under the law.
In an interview with the Associated Press Dimmig said, “My office represents indigent people, and they ought to be entitled to the same punishment for the same offenses as someone who has money. If they can’t pay . . . they are unable to get the same deal. This violates the principle of equal protection.”
State Attorney Jerry Hill defends the practice. He is the elected state attorney for the counties of Polk, Highlands, and Hardee which make up Florida’s 10th judicial circuit in central Florida. He told the AP his office depends on the fees defendants are required to pay to run his office. He acknowledged the prosecutor considers a defendant’s financial status when prosecuting a case. If the defendant can not afford to pay the fees he does not get a plea deal.
Hill stated, “Nobody is being forced to pay the cost of prosecution. They can always say ‘no.’ They are welcome to go to trial.”
Public Defender Dimmig presented a specific case on his work load he said illustrates the problem: This client was arrested and charged with driving with a suspended license, a third degree felony. In a plea bargain negotiation, State Attorney Hill’s office offered to reduce the charge to a second degree misdemeanor with no jail time or felony conviction, or any other penalty, for a fee/fine of $1,000.
If the defendant did not have a thousand dollars he would be required to take his case to trial where he would likely be found guilty of the felony and could be sentenced to the state penitentiary for up to five years. The felony conviction would cause him to lose the right to vote, disqualify him from holding some jobs, he would lose the right to possess firearms, and he would face a host of other disqualifications.
Prosecutor Hill said this is a good case for a plea bargain negotiation because it is a nonviolent felony. He said the defendant is not being pressured. He has a choice. He can pay up or take his chances before a judge and/or jury. He acknowledged that the practice was once considered “perfectly taboo.” He said it became necessary because the state legislature does not fully fund his office.
The Brennan Center for Justice has faulted the Florida courts for being overly dependent on fees from defendants. The highly respected center has warned that raising funds in such a way may cause miscarriages of justice. The Brennan Center is located on the campus of New York University and is held in high esteem nationally. It is named in honor of former U.S. Supreme Court Justice William Brennen, who was known for his integrity as h served on the high court for 34 years. The center claims its mission is to advocate for “the twin American ideals of democracy of and equal justice for all.”
In Florida “cash register justice” is not limited to court fees and fines. Prisons and jails are big business. Inmates are frequently charged fees for things like rent for their jail cell, medical care, use the jail telephone, and are charged inflated prices on commissary items purchased to supplement the jail house food served on the mess hall main line.
Indigent prisoners say their families are broke, too. They say many of them resort to criminal activities to raise money to pay court fees and to fill the needs of their imprisoned family members or loved ones. Court programs administered under the “cash register” justice system seem to be counter-productive. Instead of being a deterrent to crime they seem to be the cause of criminal activities.
State Attorney Jerry Hill asked, “Is it good or bad? One can draw their own conclusions. But that’s the reality of 2015.”
Public Defender Dimmig has vowed to work to get the Florida legislature to change the laws that legalize the practice.